What if there were a child who could not pick up socks? What if that child could not manage to get any dirty clothes off the floor? What if that child, when about to be caught by the Big Bad Mother, decided to stuff dirty clothes, wadded up, into the drawer of clean clothes? (I know. I know. This is so far-fetched as to be almost unbelievable. But just stretch your imagination....) Imagine also that this child is so opposed to picking up clothes that sometimes it's just easier to throw clean clothes (perhaps something she tried on, or wore for 15 minutes) into the dirty-clothes hamper so that she doesn't have to be bothered with folding it and putting it away in her drawer or on a hanger.
The Big Bad Mother decides that it is important to teach such a child some basic self-care skills. The BBM thinks that learning to brush teeth and brush hair and pick up clothes is even more important than math and spelling. The BBM spends an entire school year making such simple skills the priority of the day, trying to pass on the responsibility for these skills to the child. After months, it appears that maybe a little of this is beginning to sink in. So the mother continues to back off slowly, checking up on the child periodically, and normally finding those skills slipping -- slowly at first, but then precipitously.
How can this be remedied? The logical solution would be to allow "natural consequences" (one of those buzzwords in parenting advice today). If the child does not put the dirty clothes in the hamper, child will have to do her own laundry. But she wouldn't. She is perfectly content to wear clothes with ketchup splotches and peanut butter smears. There's also the problem that the Big Bad Mother would have to buy more clothes for the child, so as to make a whole load of laundry, and not allow the child to wash 3 shirts, thus wasting water and electricity and detergent. Buying more clothes involves also finding more dresser-space to store such clothes. And more clothes just means that soon the bedroom dresser will no longer be resting on its feet, but perched precariously on the pile of clothing that has been smashed under it, causing it (to all outward appearances) to be levitating.
Another solution would be to engage in that whole "behavior modification" thing. But when the Big Bad Mother is already stressed with too much to do, too much to keep track of, too many places to be, too many lessons to teach, the last thing BBM needs is to be monitoring whether Messy Child gets a star or a demerit every 15 minutes. Besides, BBM already tried something like that, and as soon as the mother's constant involvement is curtailed, bad habits return like a stubborn weed.
Sometimes it seems entirely hopeless.
Wednesday, July 04, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Dear BBM,
ReplyDeleteI don't have an answer for you but boy, can I relate, both to the hairbrushing and the messiness. I have tried the nagging until I'm blue in the face approach and I have tried the hands off in hopes that it might encourage some personal responsibility approach. So far no lasting results. Please let me know if you find the answer!
Empathetically yours,
NQ (Nagging Queen)
That child lives here too and I basically took most of his clothes away so there were less to get dumped on the ground, less to 'organize', less to destroy and cost me more money. Did that solve the problem? No, not entirely but he now has less clothes to destoy and keep track of. FWIW.
ReplyDeleteKarin who also empathizes
Karin, we don't have many clothes here. She has 2-3 pairs of pants and 2-3 pairs of shorts. So the clutter in the bedroom can't get too bad even if everything is on the floor. But that is why I don't want to put her in charge of doing her own laundry, because she would need more clothes so as to be able to fill a load. What drives me totally bonkers is the utter inability to distinguish between what is clean and what is dirty-but-wearable and what is filthy.
ReplyDeleteCheryl, we finally resorted to short hair when the hairbrushing was impossible to accomplish. But she didn't like it because people thought she looked like a boy. Then there's also the problem that comes with short hair: you have to keep cutting it so it keeps its shape and style. Nevertheless, I'm about ready to tell her the hair has to go again.
We have also had shorter hair in the past--but not really, really short (even if I could bring myself to make her do it Dad would not be pleased)--I recently informed her that at the next haircut we are going significantly shorter. Maybe if I could get her to pull it back or put it in a ponytail or let me braid it or seomthing--but she just likes to wear it down. On the one hand I like that she is not too preoccupied with her appearance--on the other hand, a touch of vanity might not be such a bad thing!
ReplyDeletePerhaps an old fashioned washboard and a bucket to do her own laundry? It wouldn't take too long to wash 3 shorts and a few shirts in a bucket every few days. Might give her incentive to keep the ketchup and PB off the clothes, too? I'd confiscate anything she refused to wash, if neccesary. Maybe that's too radical... Guess I have some BBM tendencies, too. :)Who am I to say, really - my kid is five. :\
ReplyDeleteSusan,
ReplyDeleteWE have the same problem with a really tall boy. I make him buy most of his own clothes, except birthdays. I thought he would mind if I just started piling things on the floor in his closet, clean and dirty. He thought it was a great idea we should have implemented sooner! For him, the Marines might be the only thing to fix this problem. I feel your pain.
Laura
Susan you are cracking me up. Sigh. Is it just in the category of somewhat normal to not care if they are clean or dirty? We sort of kid that when our tall boy who can't handle this either notices girls then suddenly he will get it together. When his room is clean my eye brows may raise. Our tall boy takes a shower and then puts his dirty clothes back on!
ReplyDelete